Toasted Teddy has quickly become one of Rhode’s most popular shades thanks to its flattering neutral tone that adds a natural sun-kissed flush to the cheeks.
Whether you prefer cream sticks, liquid blushes, or powder formulas, there are plenty of alternatives that capture the same warm terracotta-rose vibe as Toasted Teddy.
Toasted Teddy Dupes
Glossier Cloud Paint Gel Cream Blush “Storm” | Buy at Glossier or Sephora.
Glossier Cloud Paint in Storm has long been a cult favorite for those seeking a rich rose-brown blush. While slightly deeper and more pigmented than Toasted Teddy, it creates a very similar natural flush once blended out.
HALF MAGIC Soft Blur Cream Blush “Magic Brownie” | Buy at Ulta.
For a unique cream-to-powder finish, Half Magic Cheek Fluff in Magic Brownie offers a warm cocoa-rose tone that’s surprisingly similar to Toasted Teddy. The soft-focus finish gives cheeks a blurred, natural look.
r.e.m. beauty Eclipse Cheek & Lip Stick “Cab-eret” | Buy at Amazon, Ulta or r.e.m..
Cabaret offers a deeper rosy-brown tone with a creamy texture that works beautifully on both cheeks and lips. The shade gives the same sophisticated neutral warmth that makes Toasted Teddy so popular.
e.l.f. Camo Liquid Blush “Bronze Bombshell” | Buy at Ulta, e.l.f. or Amazon.
If you’re looking for an affordable option, e.l.f. Camo Liquid Blush in Bronze Bombshell offers a rich warm brown-rose tone that resembles Rhode’s viral shade. A tiny amount goes a long way thanks to the highly pigmented formula.
Ulta Beauty Collection Too Cheeky Lip & Cheek Stick “Debut” | Buy at Ulta.
Debut from Ulta Beauty’s Too Cheeky collection delivers a creamy rosy-brown color that’s easy to blend and build. The stick format also makes it a great alternative for Rhode fans who enjoy on-the-go application.
Best for: Quick touch-ups throughout the day.
Covergirl TruBlend Skin Enhancer Blush Balm “Toasted Chai” | Buy at Ulta or Target.
One of the most affordable Rhode alternatives, Covergirl Toasted Chai features a warm brown-rose tone in an easy-to-use balm formula. The finish is lightweight, blendable, and ideal for achieving a natural everyday flush.
MAC Skinfinish Colorstruck Blush “Raizing The Roof” | Shop at MAC or Ulta.
While technically a bronzer, MAC Raizin the Roof works beautifully as a blush on many skin tones. The warm terracotta-brown undertones create a very similar effect to Toasted Teddy, especially for those who enjoy a slightly more sculpted look.
Bonus Dupe:
Saie Dew Liquid Blush “Spicy” | Buy at Amazon, Sephora or SAIE.
One of the closest liquid blush alternatives to Toasted Teddy is Saie Dew Blush in Spicy. This liquid formula delivers a warm rosy-brown flush with a dewy finish that closely mimics the fresh, skin-like look of Rhode’s Pocket Blush.
